I've been hanging around this site and a couple of other quit sites for a few years now. I'm on day 1267 tobacco free and 1197 nicotine free. I've seen a lot of people give up nicotine using a lot of different methods. I don't know of any method that absolutely doesn't work. I've seen people succeed by using the cut down method, by mixing fake snuff with real snuff and gradually reducing the real snuff, by using the patch, by using the gum, using fake snuff, by hypnosis, by going cold turkey, by using prescripton drugs and I've seen people have to start over after trying all of those methods. The only way I know for sure that absolutely won't work is to not try.
There are too many varibles involved to say that a particular method will work every time. Quitting is an ongoing process. You not only have to quit, get through the withdrawal period, build new habits and make new associations, you have to NOT choose to start back up. Sometimes that is the hardest part of quitting and the patch, gum or whatever can't help you much with that. NRT can help you get started, but it can't keep you quit. At this point in my quit, I don't think it really matters anymore how I got through those first few weeks or months. What matters is that every day I choose to NOT have a dip. That's what makes quit sites like this one so invaluable. They give you a place to share your struggles and victories and remind you to Keep Your Guard Up.
I believe that NRT (nicotine replacement therapy) helps the most for those people who just can't get started quitting. That was my problem. I couldn't make up my mind to quit and didn't really believe that I could quit. My Aunt gave me a couple of patches to try and I found out that I could actually go a day without a dip. Finally I took the plunge and traded my copenhagen for patches. I followed the 70 day plan in the box. 6 weeks on the 21 mg patches, 2 on the 14mgs and 2 on the 7mgs I think it was. By the time I gave up the 7 mg patches I really didn't have any major withdrawal symptoms. The down side was that I'd had milder withdrawal symptoms for several weeks instead of for having the withdrawals for just a few days when I first quit...for me it was a fair trade.
One of the most important things I've seen when people use any kind of NRT is for them to have a definite plan. I've known people who had used the gum...for years. I don't believe that's a good idea. Nicotine has it's own side effects; it's not just the tobacco. I've seen several people make a plan then give up their NRT ahead of schedule and have good success with that. I didn't do that just because I knew myself and knew that I had to take away my excuses to fail. So for me, following the plan was the best option. You have to wing it a little along the way and do whatever it takes to get you through the day. If you think you're being too tempted by using the patch, gum, fake snuff or whatever, then switch over to cold turkey. You'll get nothing but support here.
One thing that I don't think is a good idea when using the patch, gum or whatever is to go back and forth with them. I subscribe to the "You Can't Have Just One" theory. I don't care if it's a patch, a cigarette, a cigar, nic gum or what. It's generally a bad idea to have one after you've went through all the trouble of going without nicotine for a few days. You might get away with it, but I have to tell you that after over Three years of wandering the halls of the quit sites and my own experience trying to give up beer, the odds are stacked HEAVILY AGAINST you. It's much easier to just not have that first one after you've weaned yourself from nicotine. I don't believe we'd be here on this site if we could have just one. You might not have one and then be back at your old level of consumption the next day, but time and time again, I've seen people have "just one" then I see them a couple of months later and they're just doing it on weekends, then a couple months later they're right back where they started and have to make that tough decision to give it up again and go back through the withdrawals.
Sorry, didn't mean to ramble on, I keep getting distracted.
I had dipped since I was a teen and by the time I finally got around to quitting when I was 47, I'd come up with a million excuses why I couldn't quit over the years. The patch helped me shoot down those excuses. I believe the patch can certainly work for you if you make a plan and get your head right. All I know for sure is that it worked for me.
I know that the patch isn't the best method for everyone. You have to find your own way through the quitting process. If you can go cold turkey and get through that first week or so on your own (with the help of this site of course) then you're probably better off doing it that way I think. If you just can't get started, then maybe it'd be worth trying the patch.
Use the tools this site gives you and it'll increase your odds no matter what method you decide to use. Keep quitting, Post and Read a lot, don't get ahead of yourself (take it a day at a time) and you'll get to where you want to be. It's gotten me to 1267 days so far.
This quittin' stuff is worth the effort.